History, Memory, and Repentance
“America is built on the blood of Native Americans and enslaved Africans. It is not the promised land. And what it has become is the rot that has always been underneath the jingoism and nationalism.” The historian Anthea Butler’s words are deliberately unsettling. They are meant to be. Whether one agrees with every part of her diagnosis or not, the force of the statement lies in its refusal of a familiar American assumption: that our problems are recent departures from an otherwise innocent national story. Many Americans have long imagined the nation through biblical imagery. The continent became a promised land. Settlers became pilgrims. Expansion became destiny. Prosperity became evidence of blessing. The language changed over the centuries, but the structure remained remarkably consistent. America was not merely a nation. It was a nation with a providential purpose. The difficulty is that there has always been another story beneath that story. The land was already inhabited. The...