Paul Ricoeur and the Trinity: Relational Identity, Narrative Selfhood, and Divine Unity

 Paul Ricoeur’s Oneself as Another offers profound insights into selfhood, identity, and otherness, themes that have captured the interest of theologians engaging with the doctrine of the Trinity. While Ricoeur does not directly address Trinitarian theology in this work, his philosophical concepts have been fruitfully applied to Trinitarian discussions in several ways.

Ricoeur’s emphasis on relational identity resonates deeply with the Trinitarian understanding of God as a communion of persons. Just as the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are distinct yet interrelated, Ricoeur’s work suggests that identity itself is inherently relational, formed and understood through relationships with others. His concept of narrative identity, the idea that individuals construct their sense of self through the stories they tell, finds parallels in the Trinitarian narrative of Christian theology. The unfolding story of salvation history, in which the Father sends the Son and the Spirit acts to bring all creation into unity, reflects the dynamic and relational interplay of the three divine persons.

Ricoeur’s exploration of the self’s encounter with the “Other” also enriches theological reflection on the unity and diversity of the Trinity. The distinct persons of the Trinity exist in a relationship of mutual otherness, yet they are united in their shared essence. This mutuality and interplay of difference and unity in the divine life echo Ricoeur’s philosophical insights into how selfhood is shaped by its interaction with otherness.

Theological scholars have drawn on Ricoeur’s philosophy to deepen the understanding of Trinitarian concepts. In The Deferred Self: Paul Ricoeur’s Oneself as Another, John L. Meech explores how Ricoeur’s ideas about selfhood and otherness can inform theological anthropology and shed light on the relational nature of the Trinity. Similarly, Henry Venema’s article, “Oneself as Another or Another as Oneself?” examines how Ricoeur’s linking of self and otherness offers a framework that moves beyond modern philosophical theories of identity, opening up possibilities for understanding the relational dynamics within the Trinity.

These reflections suggest that Ricoeur’s philosophical framework provides valuable tools for articulating the relational and narrative dimensions of Trinitarian theology. By engaging Ricoeur’s work, theologians are able to enrich their discourse on the nature of divine personhood and unity, drawing from his insights into the complexities of relational identity, narrative selfhood, and the transformative encounter with otherness.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Despair is, at its core, an act of presumption

  At a time of deep despair, when John Claypool felt the darkness closing in, an elderly rabbi offered him a piece of wisdom that reframed his struggle: “Despair is the only unforgivable sin for a Jew.” The rabbi explained that despair is, at its core, an act of presumption. It declares with certainty that no hope is left and that the future holds nothing but the weight of our present sorrow. And yet, the rabbi pointed out, this is a future we have not seen and cannot predict. In presuming to know the outcome, despair claims authority over time and God’s possibilities, which none of us possess. This wisdom is a reminder of humility. None of us can see beyond the present moment, yet our faith invites us to trust what we cannot see—that God’s grace may break through in ways we cannot imagine. Even in the darkest moments, this stance of humility keeps the door to hope open. Claypool’s encounter with the rabbi challenges us to resist despair, not by pretending we do not hurt, but by h...
Read more

The Bible in One Hand and the Newspaper in the Other

I'm thinking about my sermon for this coming Sunday.  The texts are: Jeremiah 17:5-10, Psalm 1, 1 Corinthians 15:12-20, Luke 6:17-26 **** You’ve built your life on what seemed like an unshakable foundation—your career, your family, your plans for the future. Everything feels solid, reliable—until suddenly, it begins to crack. You get the phone call you weren’t expecting. The doctor gives you the news you feared. The job you thought would last forever disappears overnight. You find yourself standing in the rubble of what used to be solid ground. This isn’t just a personal experience; we see it reflected in the world around us. Consider the recent earthquake in Turkey and Syria, where thousands of lives were lost, and entire communities were reduced to rubble in a matter of moments. Homes, schools, and businesses—all the things people relied on for security—gone in an instant. News reports speak of survivors clinging to hope, waiting for rescue beneath the debris, their lives hanging...
Read more

What have you given up for Lent?

Has anyone asked you this year:  “What have you given up for Lent?” As a sign of sacrifice and self-discipline, Christians often will “fast” (abstain) from something during the season of Lent.  We do so partly to imitate Jesus when he went into the desert to pray and fast for 40 days.  We read the story of Jesus going into the desert and being tempted by Satan on the first Sunday of Lent.  Inspired by the example of Jesus, some Christians therefore, fast for the 40 days of Lent. As you know, season of Lent begins on Ash Wednesday (better known to some as the day after Mardi Gras), and lasts 40 days (not counting Sundays, which are always feast days).   Fasting during Lent is not required of Episcopalians, though many do observe the season by fasting (giving something up for Lent).  Strictly speaking there are only two “fasts” on the Episcopal church calendar:  Ash Wednesday, and Good Friday. But, for our Roman Catholic brothers and sisters in Christ, a...
Read more